Wednesday, March 4, 2009

Of slums, dogs, barbers and terrorism

So much has been written and spoken about Slumdog Millionaire that there is hardly anything more to it. People have loved it, hated it, abused it, and used it and so on. Last week, a long well-written piece from someone in my extended family landed in my mailbox, which had a different perspective – the Mumbai portrayed in SM is not the real Mumbai, and that the movie was exaggerated. Some extracts from the post:

“Amitabh Bacchan can undoubtedly be called one of the greatest Bollywood superstars, but to show that a person can literally jump in a pool of goop for the sake of an autograph is a mere misrepresentation.”

“Other inconsistencies which I am coerced to mention are the scene in which the Sardar in the train throws off Salim and Jamal of the train for stealing a roti. Even the most cynical person might not think of performing such an inhumane act, but it adds up to the list of stereotypes. Another one is when the American couple’s chauffeur coldheartedly beats and kicks Jamal, whereupon he says to the tourists, “You wanted to see a bit of real India, here it is” and the American lady replies, “Well, here is a bit of the real America son” and hints towards her husband to give a hefty sum of a hundred dollars to Jamal. What is Boyle trying to give the impression of India as?”

I would agree that these are intelligent observations and credit to the author for these. However, why is it that we cringe in our seats every time someone holds a mirror in front of us to see the real us? How many cases have we heard over the years of people being thrown off a running train for the sake of a two rupee note? Or for a ten rupee ticket? Or for not paying off a few rupees as bribe? Have we not either gotten off a local train in Bombay to observe (often participate) in thrashing a pickpocket at the railway station for stealing a few rupees or more? C’mon guys, lets get real. These are incidents that have become a part of our daily lives and we are now immune to these observations – unless of course someone from outside the system (or country) points it out to us. I am tired of answering questions for foreign guests about the “ownership of stray cattle on the road” or “how people can just pick up a fight without the cops intervening.” Did Abhishek Bachchan not strike a chord when he slapped the local cop back in Delhi 6 post the duffer not understanding his human rights logic?

And what was Boyle trying to give the impression of India when the American woman hands him a $100 bill? The response of the audience in the hall was an answer enough. Everyone cringed, but nobody dares to acknowledge. I am not for kids begging of the streets, but if you have to give – then give them something that can help them. I can take this call today as I am aware of the beggar rackets, etc (well captured in SM) and am convinced the money will go into someone’s cash box. How do you expect an American to know that?

If people can slit their wrists for move starts and send them letters written in blood, then jumping into poop is just another way of getting around their desperation to seek the star’s attention. I thought the scene was one of the defining moments of the movie, which I will not forget in a long time to come.

And why make an issue with the name? If we can have movies called Kameeney, what’s wrong with SM? Just because the idiots who were protesting and the judge who upheld their demand for change of name did not go to school and learn English, they have no right to bark up the wrong tree. Oops! Did I just call them dogs?

And since when did barbers in India become ‘hairdressers’? A barber is a barber and will remain one for times to come, and I have great respect fro these folks. Who else can make your Sunday with a nice haircut on those old fashioned chairs and the relaxing champi. It would not have made a difference if the movie was called Billu Carpenter or Billu Tailor, it would have remained as sweet as it was. The very fact that the Parsis have not protested against their last names that outline their forefathers’ professions is proof enough that their mind has not been corrupted by a few mindless asses.

Finally, my take on Slumdog Millionaire – a ‘good’ movie made for the global audience from a Brit’s perspective. Was it worth the awards – I don’t know and frankly I don’t care. I saw it, liked it, took a message away from it, and that I what makes it a successful movie for me. While each one is entitled to his/her own opinion and observations, I feel we Indians are not sporting enough to have someone point out the ‘not-so-good’ part of us.

The other issue troubling me is the way the world has pounced on Pakistan post the attack on the Sri Lankan team. The Indian political setup and television majors have virtually declared information war on Pakistan. Last night, Barkha Dutt on NDTV and Rajdeep Sardesai on CNN-IBN went on rambling about why Pakistan should be banned as a cricket venue, how people in Pakistan are unsafe, etc.

Let me clarify - I completely condemn this act and there is no doubt that this will impact the country’s status as an international cricket host. Also, this is an act of cowardice and am not too sure what message the people behind this were trying to send. I like someone’s thought on NDTV last night – “India is a victim of Pakistan-based terrorism, and Pakistan is a victim of its own terrorism”

However, what if this unfortunate incident had happened in India? Worse… involving the Pakistan cricket team! How would the same set of people or institutions react to that?

Think about it…

No comments:

Post a Comment